Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
Destinations
USA and CanadaEuropeAustralia and NZAsiaLatin AmericaCaribbean IslandsAfrica
Travel Types
Air TravelCruisesRV Travel

Travel Forum / Destinations / USA and Canada / February 2006



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Monument Valley?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Todd Michel McComb - 27 Feb 2006 00:58 GMT
Is there a recommended travel guidebook for visiting Monument Valley
and Navajo Nation in general?  I'd ideally like something covering
lodging, dining, guided hiking/horseback tours, and unguided hiking.
Thanks.
Caveat - 27 Feb 2006 03:03 GMT
>Is there a recommended travel guidebook for visiting Monument Valley
>and Navajo Nation in general?  I'd ideally like something covering
>lodging, dining, guided hiking/horseback tours, and unguided hiking.

The Navajos generally don't seek out tourism -- especially (as they
see it) from their conquerors and oppressors. The level of
anti-outsider sentiment has grown significantly in recent years. Many
areas formerly open to "outsiders"  have been closed in recently:

"All hiking activity is hereby permanently closed. These actions set
forth are for safety precautions as well as preservation of historic
and sacred sites. The Kaibeto Chapter hereby requests the book
publishers, media, and etc. to cease all prints and advertisement to
the public on hiking anywhere within the Kaibeto vicinity."
http://www.blackrabbit.com/navajo.htm

Virtually all travel/hiking areas within the Rez now require permits
or guides. And these services are not either inexpensive nor easy to
get. This is a pity because some of the best of the Southwestern US
canyon country can only be seen on the Navajo Reservation. Some areas
are simply closed, like the Inscription House Ruins, Tsegi Canyon,
etc.

http://www.nps.gov/nava/adhi/adhi5c.htm

There are numerous books and reports that detail the amazing natural
wonders on Navajo lands -- primarily along the south side of Lake
Powell in the Navajo Mountain area. But access is difficult, the
natives are not very friendly, and the required permits are severely
limited. But this is truly wondrous country worthy of extreme effort.

There are people on the Reservation, of course, who will take
advantage of their unique offerings and profit from tourism. But the
costs are extremely high. Monument Valley and Antelope Canyon are good
examples of this. You can still see these places, but bring money.

The Navajo Reservation is a sovereign area, not considered part of the
United States, and they make their own rules. If you observe those
rules, great treasures can be found. But it isn't easy.

http://www.nps.gov/rabr/adhi/adhi5.htm
http://www.nps.gov/rabr/changes.htm

People interested in hiking the legendary North and South Rainbow
Trails can still do so, but things are getting more difficult. Hikers
are no longer permitted to walk under Rainbow Bridge in the National
Monument, for instance (the main access trail from Lake Powell to
these trails). And finding the trailheads from the south (for 15+ mile
backpacks) is difficult. But it can be done for the determined few.

Similarly, the Hopi Salt Trail is still open (with permit), but very
difficult to find. The trail is tough and leads into the bowels of the
Grand Canyon and the Sipapu holy place (off limits according to the
GCNP). and very few people do that trail these days.

Happily, my wife and I have done these trails during more lenient
times. But the time is fast approaching when these will no longer be
available. So if you want to see these places off the beaten track, go
soon. Time is running out.

Caveat


Hatunen - 27 Feb 2006 04:02 GMT
>Is there a recommended travel guidebook for visiting Monument Valley
>and Navajo Nation in general?  I'd ideally like something covering
>lodging, dining, guided hiking/horseback tours, and unguided hiking.
>Thanks.

AAA has an Indian Country map that's pretty good. Has guide to
what to do on the back. Canyon de Chelly is a MUST DO. Take the
all-day tour. The tours are done in old military 6x6s.

Lodging on the reservation is pretty limited. Get the AAA travel
guide if you can.


  ************* DAVE HATUNEN (hatunen@cox.net) *************
   *       Tucson Arizona, out where the cacti grow         *
   * My typos & mispellings are intentional copyright traps *
Caveat - 27 Feb 2006 04:46 GMT
>... Canyon de Chelly is a MUST DO. Take the
>all-day tour. The tours are done in old military 6x6s.

Agree with Dave that the Canyon de Chelly (pronounced "Canyon de
Shay") is one of the best tours in the Southwest. Camping is free in
the National Monument, but you must have a guide to go into the Canyon
de Chelly/Canyon del Muerto complex (as well as other Reservation
backcountry areas like Monument Valley, BTW). If you have your own 4wd
vehicle, however,you can hire a Navajo guide (at the Canyon de Chelly
Visitor's Center) and drive your own vehicle into the canyons (with
the guide). This is a highly recommended trip and includes visits to
many prehistoric Anasazi cliff house ruins.

Caveat
Todd Michel McComb - 27 Feb 2006 04:58 GMT
>Agree with Dave that the Canyon de Chelly (pronounced "Canyon de
>Shay") is one of the best tours in the Southwest.

Yeah, that was definitely in the plans.  Getting information on
things that are administered by the NPS is pretty easy.  It's the
other things where I'm not sure how to learn the possibilities.

Thanks for your remarks.

I did think about consulting AAA as a fallback, but was hoping for
something a little more detailed on lodging/dining.
Caveat - 27 Feb 2006 16:55 GMT
>Thanks for your remarks.
>I did think about consulting AAA as a fallback, but was hoping for
>something a little more detailed on lodging/dining.

Quite limited. Page is the big town in the northern part, with pretty
good services (because of the GCNRA). Tuba City and Kayenta have very
limited offerings (a few motels and low-end restaurants). Mexican Hat
is smaller. Chinle is a bustling little town with somewhat better
tourist offerings (because of the Canyon de Chelly). Other than that,
there's not much out there. The big city off the Rez to the South is
Flagstaff. One can get most anything there.

Caveat
JamesStep@gmail.com - 27 Feb 2006 18:06 GMT
> Is there a recommended travel guidebook
> for visiting Monument Valley and Navajo
> Nation in general?

You might just want to visit a large bookstore and browse the various
travel guides for the southwest U.S. and see which one best suits your
interests. Often the different guidebook companies have different
approaches and a guidebook that appeals to one person may not appeal to
someone else.

Some of those guidebook companies also post some of their info online;
for example at the Frommers site they have several pages about Monument
Valley (not much about hiking, although they mention a couple companies
that offer hiking tours)...

http://www.frommers.com/destinations/monumentvalley/1939010029.html

(On the left side of that page are links to their other pages about
Monument Valley.)

Jim
SMS - 27 Feb 2006 21:04 GMT
> Is there a recommended travel guidebook for visiting Monument Valley
> and Navajo Nation in general?  I'd ideally like something covering
> lodging, dining, guided hiking/horseback tours, and unguided hiking.
> Thanks.

Check the Rough Guide Southwest USA book. Chapter one has some stuff on
those two areas.
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.